News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Tidal havoc 

Tidal havoc

13 May, 2009 05:23 PM
THE wild winds, low pressure and high tide on the Anzac Day weekend damaged many parts of the Port Phillip coastline and prompted the question: has dredging of The Heads allowed greater storm surges to enter the bay?

Reports have been coming into The Mail since April 26 when parts of Victoria were hit by winds of up to 120kmh with the peninsula copping gusts of more than 90kmh.

One of the highest tides in recent years was caused by strong westerlies and a huge low-pressure system crossing the state.

Many beaches on the eastern shore of Port Phillip were damaged, including:

Portsea - Judith Muir of Polperro Dolphin Swims said the storm surge destroyed a pass that connects Weeroona Bay west of Portsea pier to the pier-side beach. "There are huge holes in the seawall and a path 1.5-2metres above sea level collapsed."

Blairgowrie - the beach is being renourished with tonnes of earth, but not much remains of the roadside verge separating the highway from the sea, Ms Muir says.

McCrae - the storm surge obliterated the beach near the main car park and exposed rocks not seen in living memory.

Dromana - Kirsty Barger and The Mail's Yanni captured graphic images of how much sand had been washed away from just north of the Dromana boat launching ramp near Anthonys Nose. This included the boat hire shed at Dromana west, which was to be redeveloped into a cafe a few years ago.

Minor damage and massive inundation was also reported at Safety Beach, Mt Martha - where Balcombe estuary had been opened by earthmoving equipment just days before the storm closed the opening - Mornington (the pier was damaged, including a two-metre-thick rock wall and almost 100 planks dislodged or washed away, reported in The Mail on April 29), Mt Eliza (massive erosion including at the end of Williams Road) and Frankston, where Kananook Creek flooded properties and the pier was also damaged.

The Western Port Greenhouse Alliance warns that because of climate change such storms could occur ever six years within 20 years and every year by 2070.

The alliance covers seven councils in the south-east including Mornington Peninsula Shire.

Its award-winning report published last year, Impacts of Climate Change on Human Settlements in the Western Port Region: an Integrated Assessment, included worrying data about the threat of rising seas and more storms affecting municipalities on Port Phillip.

Water worries are set against the backdrop of the State Government warning planners they should factor in an 80-centimetre sea level rise over the next 100 years for projects near the coast.

Three recent planning decision show councils are worried about rising seas:

Casey Council has forced a home owner to install three-metre high stumps under a planned house at Warneet on the northern coast of Western Port.

Wellington Shire backed down on a ban on building homes at The Honeysuckles near Ninety Mile Beach in Gippsland, but wants home owners in low-lying coastal areas to be slugged with extra building conditions or forced to indemnify the council of any responsibility in the event of flood.

Gippsland Coastal Board stopped the building of houses at Toora on Corner Inlet overlooking Wilsons Promontory after South Gippsland Shire approved them. This was the first case in Australia where climate change has been given as a reason to refuse a coastal development.

Port Phillip channel deepening monitor Mick Bourke said late last month the bay's high tides had risen just one centimetre since dredging at The Heads ended.

Six months of tidal height data scrutinised by the Office of the Environmental Monitor showed the increase was consistent with predictions.

"The project's environmental assessment process predicted that after the entrance to the bay was deepened, tides within Port Phillip would increase around one centimetre," he said.

"Dredging at the entrance ended in September 2008, and the evidence from tidal height monitoring to date shows us that tidal height changes in the order of one centimetre are beginning to be detected within the bay.

"High tides have risen up to one centimetre and low tides have decreased by a similar amount."

Mr Bourke said a full year of around-the-clock tide and sea level monitoring would continue up to the end of September.

However, anti-dredging campaigner Jenny Warfe, president of Blue Wedges Coalition, quotes the controversial Bruun Rule.

"It states that for every one unit that water rises vertically it can spread up to 100 units horizontally on low-lying land," she said.

"The imperceptible 1centimetre that the PoMC and OEM talk about can mean up to 1metre of previously dry land being inundated.

"There's a lot of very important and valuable infrastructure in this zone, including in my area the main trunk sewer from Dromana to Rosebud that runs along the northern side of Point Nepean Road from Dromana. It crosses back on to the landward side of the road right where rocks are collapsing and the cliff below is eroding.

"The extra water moving in and out of Port Phillip on every tide change, as a result of dredging, was calculated in the 2004 EES to be 20million cubic metres. This may not seem to be much when spread out over the entire bay, but the extra volume and weight of water must contribute to erosion, especially during storm surges, low pressure and 'high' high tides."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
This article is typical of what is now going to be recognised as "the norm" around all our coastline. Once erosion starts, it is impossible to hold back, every surge tide is now going to cause more and more erosion biting further into the land, we don't control nature - it controls us. Just remember Mr Garret, you're making your name famous for being an idiot passing permission for this raping of the coastline of Port Phillip Bay.
Posted by Pam Edwards, 16/05/2009 11:58:17 AM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

1) Apple iPhone 4 32GB43 plans 1%
2) Apple iPhone 4 16GB44 plans 7%
3) HTC Desire4 plans 3%
4) Apple iPhone 3GS 8GB33 plans 1%
5) Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini Pro37 plans 1%

Mobile Phones | Broadband Plans

Get the best deal at Fairfax Digital - Rural Press



The Mornington and Southern Peninsula Mail







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Navigate

Classifieds

More Ways to Read

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2010. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...